Friday, August 04, 2006

ISRAEL @ WAR: Hey, brother, got any smokes?

Yesterday, I had the distinct honor of traveling up north to bring our soldiers some relief supplies. (I won't go into the details of the trip in this post short of saying that I was fortunate that none of the 200+ katyusha rockets that Hezbollah fired into northern communities in Israel yesterday - killing 8 people - landed in our vicinity).

I am privileged to live in a community that has raised a lot of money and supplies that have been put towards making the lives of our soldiers up north just a little bit easier during these difficult times. Among the items that we were given to deliver to our soldiers yesterday were: junk food, deodorant, shampoo, toothpaste, underwear, socks, undershirts... and cigarettes.

Over the course of the 3+ hour car ride up north, from my home to just south of Kiryat Shemonah, I had a lengthy discussion with my friend Josh, as to whether it was appropriate for us to be bringing our soldiers cigarettes.

Here are the two sides of the debate, as we saw it:


* While smoking may not be good for you, it is socially / societally acceptable, and as such, it's not for us to decide whether a soldier should or shouldn't be smoking.

* While it may be a fact that smoking is unhealthy (in the long term), if smoking will help calm the nerves of our soldiers (those who smoke) and thus help them to carry out their duties more successfully, then by giving them cigarettes, we might be helping them (in the short term).


* By giving our soldiers cigarettes, we are basically poisoning them - the very opposite of the purpose of our mission.

* It is highly problematic, according to Jewish Law.

What would you do?

JBlog Me


Give them the cigarettes. End of discussion.

By Blogger tafka PP, at Sun Aug 06, 02:30:00 PM GMT+3  

As one of the soldiers who was on the northern border, who does not smoke, but did have to put up with sitting inside a tomat (moving cannon - around the same size as a tank) while someone smoked, I would rather you hadn't brought them.

By Anonymous H, at Mon Aug 28, 01:23:00 PM GMT+3  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

<< Home

Blogwise - blog directory Blogarama - The Blogs Directory