Monday, May 28, 2007

Why should anyone care about Sderot?

With no end in sight to the 6 year long rocket assault on Sderot, Ari Shavit of Ha'aretz elaborates upon why those in Israel should give a damn:
It should not have been like this. Sderot is not Gush Katif. There is no debate. On the contrary: Sderot is a "Green Line" city. Sderot is a post-withdrawal city. Sderot is the righteous Israeli city after the occupation. Sderot is the future
Which leads us to Shavit's main point. Why should Israelis care about Sderot?
The attack on Sderot is a strategic attack on peace. It is an attack on the two-state solution. If the attack succeeds, there will be no chance of any future withdrawal. If the attack succeeds, the occupation will be perpetuated.
In Shavit's world,, one should care about Sderot, not because of the responsibility one Jew has for another - or even that of one human being for another, nor is he driven by the pursuit of justice. The sole reason one should care about Sderot is because if Sderot falls, so does the "peace process".

While Shavit makes the distinction between Sderot and Gush Katif clear, he fails to grasp a major distinction existing between Israel and the Arab world, which serves as the root cause for the tragedy that is Sderot.

If one looks at the "Palestinian Authority" map above, there is no green line. No distinction is made between Gush Katif and Sderot. No distinctions are needed for the simple reason that the entire Land of Israel (Palestine) belongs to them - to Islam.

If one looks at the nobility of Israeli society, what does one find? As Shavit puts it:
Sderot should have been the apple of the eye of all those preaching withdrawal in the past, and of everyone who still believes in withdrawal. Sderot should have been the city of peace writers and peace singers and peace industrialists. A "peace now" city. A city of Israeli solidarity. A city of mutual responsibility. A city where strong Israelis stand together with Israelis who are less strong in the face of Islamic zealotry.
Yet, what one finds amongst the vast majority of Israels elite is a group who questions the very right of the Jewish People to a Jewish State in the Land of Israel. After all, can it be said that Gush Katif is really anymore "occupied territory" than Sderot? Certainly there's no difference in the eyes of the Arabs. Which is why, if, as Shavit puts it, Sderot is Israel's future, then it's clear that Israel's nobility has already abandoned ship.

When Ariel Sharon said that the fate of Netzarim is that of Tel Aviv (April, 2002), he was not mistaken. Until the Jewish People recognize their absolute right to the Land of Israel and show that they are willing and able to enforce that right, there will be no peace. Not in Gush Katif. Not in Sderot. Not in Jerusalem and not in Tel Aviv.

The time has come for us - those who still believe in this fundamental and historic truth - to assume the leadership and responsibility of this country and to do so before Sderot falls.

Labels: , , , ,


I think the Jordainians might have something to say about that map. Where is the "west bank" on that map? BTW I will never take Bartolo Colon in a trade.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tue May 29, 12:48:00 AM GMT+3  


I would consider it a privilege if you would add my blog "The Tygrrrr Express" to your list of linked sites if you feel the quality is high.


By Anonymous eric, at Fri Jun 08, 03:47:00 AM GMT+3  

As identified globally, replica handbags are generally reciprocated to tobacco tinted bags and handbags. But with the on-set of spring, assume more lively colors for the Wholesale replica handbags selection as most of the replica bags and other items are usually bathed within one of the most vibrant and amazingly attractive colors to for the eyes to feast and will certainly retain designer replica handbags jaws dropping for the soil.

By Blogger xinxin, at Mon Jul 12, 03:04:00 AM GMT+3  

ミュゼ 札幌駅前店
ミュゼ 新宿
ミュゼ 沖縄那覇国際通り店
スリムビューティーハウス 越谷
スリムビューティーハウス 沖縄
エルセーヌ 和泉府中
脱毛 Jエステ広島本通店
グランモア 梅田店
ソシエ 神戸 西神
たかの由梨 五反田店
たかの由梨 神戸本店
エステサロン ラ・セーヌ志木店
脱毛 BDC 秋田店
リフィート センター南店
ピュウベッロ 福岡店
ラパルレ 自由が丘店
メンズ ラパルレ藤枝店
ミスパリ 熊本店

By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sat Aug 06, 01:34:00 PM GMT+3  

Burberry Outlet Store Online
Handbags Outlet Store Online

By Blogger Simple Luxury, at Wed Oct 12, 06:21:00 PM GMT+2  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

<< Home

Blogwise - blog directory Blogarama - The Blogs Directory