Sunday, June 11, 2006

Israel: Home of the Nebs?

Even though Faith in Nathan beat me to the punch, I believe that the following issue merits reiterating (and, in any case, I had been meaning to write this post last week, so, I ask for your indulgence).

Elie Wiesel calls upon Israel to take in Darfur refugees

Nobel Prize-winning author Elie Wiesel has called on Israel to take in refugees from Darfur. In an interview in the upcoming issue of Haaretz Magazine, Wiesel, a Holocaust survivor, says, "We as Jews are obliged to help not only Jews. I was a refugee and therefore I am in favor of admitting refugees. I thought it was very laudable when Israel became the first country to admit the Vietnamese boat people. History constantly chooses a capital of human suffering, and Darfur is today the capital of human suffering. Israel should absorb refugees from Darfur, even a symbolic number."

Perhaps Elie Wiesel, in light of the above quote, can answer the following questions for me:

1) Elie Wiesel, Holocaust survivor, and self-declared refugee, decided long ago to make the United States of America his home, as such, if he is in favor of admitting refugees from Darfur, why not call upon the United States to open her borders? Could it be that Wiesel recalled the refusal of the United States to allow the Jews fleeing Europe during the Sho'ah to find refuge on her shores that lead him to turn to Israel?

2) Placing the merit of Wiesel's request aside, in choosing to make the United States his home, does Wiesel have the right to call upon the State of Israel to admit refugees from Darfur (or to implement any other policy)?

3) While Wiesel's request may be a just one, why do I get the impression that for Wiesel, the State of Israel exists merely to serve as home to refugees and others who are fleeing persecution?

Could it be, that there might actually be Jews (like myself) who have chosen to make Aliyah to the Jewish State of Israel for positive reasons, and who are proud to call Israel home?

4) Is it too difficult for Elie Wiesel to comprehend, that while he may be living a comfortable (Jewish?) life in the United States, and as such, the State of Israel exists for him solely as an option of last resort, that no amount of wishful thinking or blissful ignorance will change the fact the that today, the Jewish State of Israel is home to the single largest Jewish community in the world; is the only Jewish community in the world that can boast of a positive growth rate; is on the verge of having the majority of world Jewry living within her borders (something that has not occurred in over 2,500 years - not since the destruction of the 1st Temple), all the while, the American Jewish community continues its steady physical and spiritual decline?

I am proud to be living in the Jewish State of Israel, a state that was concerned for the well-being of the "Vietnamese boat people"; a state that, in her short history, has provided a home to hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of Jews who experienced various forms of distress and persecution throughout the world, whether from Arab countries, Ethiopia, the Former Soviet Union, France, or Argentina; a country that has reached out to nations in distress throughout the world, but do not misconstrue any of the above to believe that the State of Israel exists solely as a place of refuge for those who are persecuted or who have nowhere else to turn.

True, the Jewish State of Israel isn't quite yet the "Light unto the Nations" which our Torah and Prophets envisioned, but the challenges we face here are the challenges of the Jewish People, and by living here, I am proud to be doing my share to help the Jewish people and State overcome those challenges; proud to be living in the Land of my Forefathers, the physical, spiritual and cultural center of the Jewish world, and proud to be taking an active role in shaping the future of the Jewish State of Israel, working to ensure that it will be a place that will allow for the collective potnetial and destiny of the Jewish People to be realized...

and that's something that Elie Wiesel can only pay lip service to.

(For more on this topic, see With Friends Like You: What Israelis Really Think About American Jews by Matti Golan).


He has to keep up his image.Since we are a'richer' country than U.S.
why not us.

By Anonymous daat y, at Mon Jun 12, 02:08:00 AM GMT+3  


Once again you have chosen any old random point from the news to launch into the same old rant.

A) Jews who disagree with me and live in Galut have no right to speak about Israel. (Jews who agree with me are fine, i.e, Jonathon Pollard).

B) Jewish life outside Israel is less meaningful than Jewish life inside israel. (No arguments from me on that score)

C) Jews of America should get off their lazy behinds and make aliyah. (Once again - no argument from me.)

I have two questions though -

1) What about the suggestion which Wiesel actually made? Should we accept refugees? If not (as I assume you will say), why not? Is this not what the Torah commands us?

2) In what way are you furthering the cause of convincing American Jewry to abandon the treife medina by your constant chastisement? Why don't we make Israel more appealing to immigration of the largely non-Orthodox Jewish population?


By Anonymous H, at Mon Jun 12, 11:39:00 AM GMT+3  

Haim, nowhere did I say that Elie Wiesel could not speak his mind, I only questioned how much weight the State of Israel needed to place on his request.

2nd, Jonathan Pollard is a citizen fo the State of Israel, and was recognized by the State of Israel as having been an agent o the State, and is serving a life sentence for those actions. there is not comparisson between Polard and Wiesel.]

3rd, I am not against accepting some of these refugees per se. I would not be in favor of granting them citizenship (as would be my feelings towardsany non-Jew in Israel), but I would not be against providing them with refuge and asylum. However, I do not believe that it is up to Israel to accept all of the refugees.

4th, I think Aliyah needs to be made more appealing to all Jews, not just Orthodox and not just secular. All Jews need to be encouraged to come home.

I'm open to any suggestions.

By Blogger Ze'ev, at Mon Jun 12, 12:17:00 PM GMT+3  

replica handbags has occupied a position of pride and has an enviable following of devout buyers. Every new style released by the company Fendi handbags is lapped up by ardent fans. There is a reason for that. You see, designer bags has improved on its quality, chic, beauty, style and workmanship over the years. For example, something like the louis vuitton can make any woman stand out from the crowd; or, if you want genuine leather, try the louis vuitton handbags . Nothing can beat the style quotient of these bags.

By Blogger xinxin, at Mon Jul 12, 03:30:00 AM GMT+3

By Blogger longge, at Fri Oct 29, 10:56:00 AM GMT+2  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

<< Home

Blogwise - blog directory Blogarama - The Blogs Directory